I went over earlier the different ways of gathering raw materials in the game. What can be done with this stuff? Well, the easiest thing is to just sell it to someone else on the AH, your bazaar, or by spamming in some way. But what if you want to actually make something? How does that work, exactly?
There are 9 crafting guilds in the game and 8 of them work exactly the same way. The 9th, fishing, is mostly different but still participates in the guild point system discussed below. (This differentiates fishing from the other gathering professions.) The way you craft items in this game is you use an elemental crystal in your inventory to pop open a window with 8 slots. Hit enter on a slot to pick another item out of your inventory and add it to the crafting window. Put a bunch of stuff in the window and hit ok. If those specific items along with that specific crystal form a proper recipe and your skill level is within 9 of that recipe's level you'll try to make it. An animation will play and a couple seconds later you find out what happened. There are 5 potential outcomes from a given recipe: failure, normal success, high quality success, super high quality success, and super duper high quality success. On failure you lose the crystal and possibly some of the materials too. Each of the other 4 outcomes have fixed results based on the recipe and your chances for the higher quality successes is higher the higher your skill level is in relation to the recipe skill level.
For example, you could be trying to make apple pies. The skill cap for this recipe is 48, so you could try as soon as you were 39 but you'd get lots of failures at that point. Apple pies are food which give a 30 minute buff of 25 mp, -1 agi, 3 int. To make one, you'd use a fire crystal and then select a pie dough, a maple sugar, a cinnamon, a lizard egg, and a faerie apple from your inventory. Hit go and if you succeed you'd get 4 apple pies. Get lucky and you could get a high quality result and make 4 apple pie +1s. (Is that the proper pluralization of apple pie +1?) Apple pie +1 gives a 60 minute buff of 30 mp, 4 int, and 2 mp regen while resting. Get even luckier and make 8 apple pie +1s. Get the top tier result and make a full stack of 12 apple pie +1s.
Note you didn't need to learn how to make apple pies. Just putting the right combination of items together is good enough. You could search the game for hints on recipes or do massive trial and error. Or you could turn to the interweb and get full lists, like on these two sites.
There are all kinds of crazy theories about how to increase your odds of succeeding to make an item, or to increase your odds of getting a high quality result, or to increase your odds of leveling up. Matching the element of your crystal used with the element of the day or with the element associated with the cardinal direction you face! Or the phase of the moon, or the element of your equipped staff, or the weather going on! Nothing has ever been confirmed or denied officially. Here's a site that combines all the variables which they think matter into one spot to show where to face on what day when doing what recipe to get what result. Crazy!
Ok, so that's how to craft, but what about guilds? Why is fishing included here? Well, every craft has an artificial barrier that takes place every 10 levels. You can't skill up above level 10 without breaking that barrier and you do so at the appropriate guild. There's an NPC which asks for a specific item. Make (or buy) one of those items and trade it to the NPC to break the barrier and allow skilling up to the next 10. This is true for fishing all the way to 100 skill and for every other craft up to 60. For the other 8 crafts you can only earn a total of 40 skill levels beyond 60. So you could take one to 100, or 2 to 80, but you can't have 2 at 100. Some recipes actually use multiple crafting skills so this restriction actually limits who can make certain things.
Guilds will also provide you with a temporary skill boost if you ask for it. +1 skill for free or +3 for a fee.
Finally, you can sign up to be a premium member of one guild. Every earth day an NPC in that guild will ask for an item and will award you guild points for trading them that item. There's a cap on how many points you can earn in this way each day and pretty awesome rewards when you gather enough of them. Gear and furniture that increases your skill, or unlock the ability to make certain things, or let you sign your work. (I guess I lied when I said you could make everything without learning the recipes since you can't make sushi, for example, without buying the sushi kit thing from the cooking guild.) You can switch guilds at any time but you lose all unspent points when you do.
Friday, April 15, 2011
Thursday, April 14, 2011
Final Fantasy XI: Chocobos!
I managed to successfully run to the capital city (Jeuno) yesterday without getting killed. (There's no such thing as corpse running in FFXI. You die and you either get rezzed by someone else or you respawn at your home point. Thankfully while you do lose some experience you get to keep all your gear unlikely earlier games.) My highest level is 20 which means I met the minimum criteria for doing the chocobo quests. As best I can tell there are 4 main things you can do with chocobos; 2 of which existed back when I played before and 2 of which are completely new to me and sound to be pretty awesome.
First of all, at level 20, you can start a quest in Jeuno to heal a sick chocobo. You need 4 pieces of Gausebit Grass and you have to visit a sick chocobo and try to feed him the grass 6 times. Each time has to be on a different game day, so it takes 6 hours of real time to do. Note you can do other things in the meantime and they don't have to be consecutive game days so it's not nearly as bad as it sounds. You just need to head to the chocobo stables 6 different times. Your reward for completing this quest is a license which lets you rent a chocobo from any of a multitude of places including all major towns and the main teleport locations. Renting a chocobo costs a small amount of gil (300-1200ish) and the ride lasts for 30 minutes or until you dismount. Chocobos are like mounts in World of Warcraft in that they are substantially faster than walking but are worse in that you can only get on at the designated locations and they cost money to use. They're better in that you can't get attacked while on one so you can freely run through high level aggressive monsters without dying.
Next up, while riding a chocobo you can feed it a gysahl green (vendor price ~70gil) to make it dig for buried treasure. There is a hidden skill level associated with chocobo digging (it's a lot like fishing except you get told your fishing skill in the status menu) which helps determine what you dig up. Also the zone in which you are digging and time of day can impact what you dig up. Also, every zone on has so much stuff in it so if other people are digging at the same time they can deplete the results. Finally, there is a fatigue system (again, like fishing) so there is a cap as to how often you can dig each day. 100 digs by default, 200 with some gear. Total cost to skill up to max is estimated at around 12.6M gil! The guide I found claims that once you've invested 300k you're pretty much guaranteed to make money as long as you're hitting the right zones and they aren't cleared out already by other people. I know I used to carry a stack or two of greens on me and dig as I was riding from place to place just for fun and to see what random junk I could find but it was at a loss.
They added a new mini-game where you get to actually raise your own chocobo. You can get a quest to get an egg at level 20 and then you get to play a life management simulator for the next _FOUR_ months. Choose what your chocobo is going to do each and every hour to manage stat gains and ability gains and whatnot. Think Princess Maker 2 but with fewer buxomize pills. At any rate, after about a month of raising a chocobo you get an item which lets you summon your chocobo to you anywhere in the world. So, you can now mount up wherever you want! This item has a limited number of charges and costs 400gil per charge to recharge it, so you don't get out of paying for your rides, but you can start from anywhere which is pretty sweet. On top of that the stats your chocobo has impacts how your mount behaves when you're riding it. You can make it go faster than the rentable ones, or ride for longer, or be better at digging. There's also a racing circuit where you can ride your chocobo for various rewards and the stats your chocobo has matters for there, too. You can even breed chocobos if you want, like in FFVII, and try to make different colours or better stats. You're only ever playing the life management sim with one chocobo at a time but it sounds like you can have multiple old chocobos lying around and switch between them as you want different stat mixes.
Finally they also added in the Chocobo Hot and Cold game from FFIX. You get sent to a specific location in the world and when you get there you can dig. You get told in relative terms how close you are to the treasure and have a number of tries to find it using just a vague starting location and the hints from your chocobo. Get it right in time and get a treasure chest with some random stuff in it. It sounds fun (I certainly fully completed the Hot and Cold game in FFIX both times I played it) but I can't tell from the potential item list if it's profitable or just fun.
In conclusion everyone should get a chocobo license for sure since that quest is pretty trivial and the rewards are huge. Beyond that having the ability to call your mount from anywhere seems really useful so hatching one personal chocobo and raising it seems good. If you don't pay attention to the life management game you'll still get to call your mount anywhere (well, there is a quest in the middle to get a whistle to do it so you'd have to pay enough attention to do that) but your chocobo would have low stats and be slower than a rental if you did that. But since you could still rent in towns it wouldn't be much of a hit. And if you're like me and actually enjoy life management games and random digging then chocobos seems like a pretty fun time sink. Must make a green chocobo...
First of all, at level 20, you can start a quest in Jeuno to heal a sick chocobo. You need 4 pieces of Gausebit Grass and you have to visit a sick chocobo and try to feed him the grass 6 times. Each time has to be on a different game day, so it takes 6 hours of real time to do. Note you can do other things in the meantime and they don't have to be consecutive game days so it's not nearly as bad as it sounds. You just need to head to the chocobo stables 6 different times. Your reward for completing this quest is a license which lets you rent a chocobo from any of a multitude of places including all major towns and the main teleport locations. Renting a chocobo costs a small amount of gil (300-1200ish) and the ride lasts for 30 minutes or until you dismount. Chocobos are like mounts in World of Warcraft in that they are substantially faster than walking but are worse in that you can only get on at the designated locations and they cost money to use. They're better in that you can't get attacked while on one so you can freely run through high level aggressive monsters without dying.
Next up, while riding a chocobo you can feed it a gysahl green (vendor price ~70gil) to make it dig for buried treasure. There is a hidden skill level associated with chocobo digging (it's a lot like fishing except you get told your fishing skill in the status menu) which helps determine what you dig up. Also the zone in which you are digging and time of day can impact what you dig up. Also, every zone on has so much stuff in it so if other people are digging at the same time they can deplete the results. Finally, there is a fatigue system (again, like fishing) so there is a cap as to how often you can dig each day. 100 digs by default, 200 with some gear. Total cost to skill up to max is estimated at around 12.6M gil! The guide I found claims that once you've invested 300k you're pretty much guaranteed to make money as long as you're hitting the right zones and they aren't cleared out already by other people. I know I used to carry a stack or two of greens on me and dig as I was riding from place to place just for fun and to see what random junk I could find but it was at a loss.
They added a new mini-game where you get to actually raise your own chocobo. You can get a quest to get an egg at level 20 and then you get to play a life management simulator for the next _FOUR_ months. Choose what your chocobo is going to do each and every hour to manage stat gains and ability gains and whatnot. Think Princess Maker 2 but with fewer buxomize pills. At any rate, after about a month of raising a chocobo you get an item which lets you summon your chocobo to you anywhere in the world. So, you can now mount up wherever you want! This item has a limited number of charges and costs 400gil per charge to recharge it, so you don't get out of paying for your rides, but you can start from anywhere which is pretty sweet. On top of that the stats your chocobo has impacts how your mount behaves when you're riding it. You can make it go faster than the rentable ones, or ride for longer, or be better at digging. There's also a racing circuit where you can ride your chocobo for various rewards and the stats your chocobo has matters for there, too. You can even breed chocobos if you want, like in FFVII, and try to make different colours or better stats. You're only ever playing the life management sim with one chocobo at a time but it sounds like you can have multiple old chocobos lying around and switch between them as you want different stat mixes.
Finally they also added in the Chocobo Hot and Cold game from FFIX. You get sent to a specific location in the world and when you get there you can dig. You get told in relative terms how close you are to the treasure and have a number of tries to find it using just a vague starting location and the hints from your chocobo. Get it right in time and get a treasure chest with some random stuff in it. It sounds fun (I certainly fully completed the Hot and Cold game in FFIX both times I played it) but I can't tell from the potential item list if it's profitable or just fun.
In conclusion everyone should get a chocobo license for sure since that quest is pretty trivial and the rewards are huge. Beyond that having the ability to call your mount from anywhere seems really useful so hatching one personal chocobo and raising it seems good. If you don't pay attention to the life management game you'll still get to call your mount anywhere (well, there is a quest in the middle to get a whistle to do it so you'd have to pay enough attention to do that) but your chocobo would have low stats and be slower than a rental if you did that. But since you could still rent in towns it wouldn't be much of a hit. And if you're like me and actually enjoy life management games and random digging then chocobos seems like a pretty fun time sink. Must make a green chocobo...
Wednesday, April 13, 2011
Final Fantasy XI: Egg Event
Starting yesterday and lasting for two weeks it would seem there is an Easter related event running in Final Fantasy XI. The basic idea is every game day (56 minutes) you can talk to a specific moogle in each city in order to get a free egg. These eggs have letters on them and your goal is to spell out specific things to get rewards. With 26 different eggs and getting at most one an hour this is rather reminiscent of the World of Warcraft Hallowe'en hat event. As in, statistically improbable to get a complete set. There are several notable differences here, most importantly that the eggs are not exclusive and can therefore be sold to other players. In fact, I first realized the event was going on when I saw a huge upswing in the number of characters standing around the entrance to the zone with their bazaars turned on. (In FFXI you can mark any item in your inventory as for sale with a price and anyone inspecting you can check out what you have for sale and buy it if they like the price. I used to do this with fishing bait.) Also you don't need to get one of every letter, though you will need many copies of specific letters. Here's what you can turn in and why you might want to do so.
The first three letters of your character name. Trading these eggs to the moogle will reward you with an egg hat and the ability to hand in the rest of the sets so everyone who does the event has to do this one first. The egg is mostly a vanity item but does modify what you can dig up when you're doing the chocobo digging profession. (It makes you dig up various eggs.) It also slightly changes the way you get eggs each hour as well. Typically you get a completely random egg when you talk to the moogle but if you're in a party with someone you can force the moogle to give you the first letter of their name. (Anyone want any Zs?) If that person is wearing an egg hat you instead get two eggs matching the first two letters of their name. (How about some Is?) It's also a level 1 hat with 1 defense which is better gearwise than the no-hat I'm currently wearing on my BLM... You can also get extra eggs each hour by trading other in game eggs to the moogle but I imagine that's not terribly cost effective.
Seven of a kind. This gives you a ranged slot item with 1 vit and 1% mp. Seems ok.
Initial straight eight. This is your first initial along with the next 7 letters of the alphabet. This gives you a ranged slot item with 1 vit and 1% hp. Also seems ok. Also apparently can be obtained with a second set of seven of a kind.
Spell the name of the element associated with the current game day. This gives you a ranged slot item with 1 singing skill and a latent ability of 1 accuracy, 1 attack, and 1 evasion. You need to have a song or roll buff to get that effect. Also seems ok if you have a bard or corsair in your group.
The first 5 letters of a region. This gives you a piece of furniture based on the city that controls that region. There are a whole bunch of different egg related furniture you can get most of which seem to boost the amount of gil you loot from mobs. If you want to make your house look all eggy this is a good way to make that happen. My house is completely barren right now (what can I say, I'm poor) so maybe getting some tacky egg furniture to spruce up the joint would be nice.
Overall it doesn't seem like there's anything game breaking to get from this event and it costs a lot of precious inventory space to hold all these different types of eggs. If people are actually buying eggs it might be worth doing for some quick bucks and I kinda want a 1%mp egg just because I have no gear for that slot right now but beyond that it doesn't seem like a big deal.
The first three letters of your character name. Trading these eggs to the moogle will reward you with an egg hat and the ability to hand in the rest of the sets so everyone who does the event has to do this one first. The egg is mostly a vanity item but does modify what you can dig up when you're doing the chocobo digging profession. (It makes you dig up various eggs.) It also slightly changes the way you get eggs each hour as well. Typically you get a completely random egg when you talk to the moogle but if you're in a party with someone you can force the moogle to give you the first letter of their name. (Anyone want any Zs?) If that person is wearing an egg hat you instead get two eggs matching the first two letters of their name. (How about some Is?) It's also a level 1 hat with 1 defense which is better gearwise than the no-hat I'm currently wearing on my BLM... You can also get extra eggs each hour by trading other in game eggs to the moogle but I imagine that's not terribly cost effective.
Seven of a kind. This gives you a ranged slot item with 1 vit and 1% mp. Seems ok.
Initial straight eight. This is your first initial along with the next 7 letters of the alphabet. This gives you a ranged slot item with 1 vit and 1% hp. Also seems ok. Also apparently can be obtained with a second set of seven of a kind.
Spell the name of the element associated with the current game day. This gives you a ranged slot item with 1 singing skill and a latent ability of 1 accuracy, 1 attack, and 1 evasion. You need to have a song or roll buff to get that effect. Also seems ok if you have a bard or corsair in your group.
The first 5 letters of a region. This gives you a piece of furniture based on the city that controls that region. There are a whole bunch of different egg related furniture you can get most of which seem to boost the amount of gil you loot from mobs. If you want to make your house look all eggy this is a good way to make that happen. My house is completely barren right now (what can I say, I'm poor) so maybe getting some tacky egg furniture to spruce up the joint would be nice.
Overall it doesn't seem like there's anything game breaking to get from this event and it costs a lot of precious inventory space to hold all these different types of eggs. If people are actually buying eggs it might be worth doing for some quick bucks and I kinda want a 1%mp egg just because I have no gear for that slot right now but beyond that it doesn't seem like a big deal.
Tuesday, April 12, 2011
Immersion?
Sky commented on yesterday's post saying that he felt the level synch feature would be a big hit to the immersion factor of playing Final Fantasy XI and compared it unfavourably with World of Warcraft. I strongly disagreed with that assessment but I wasn't really sure why, so I spent some time thinking about what immersion actually means and how the two games fare. (I probably should have spent that time sleeping but when my brain gets working on something there's no turning it off.)
I did some searching and apparently the concept of immersion is a pretty fleshed out concept. Historically this has been in terms of books and revolves around the idea of "suspension of disbelief". Things in the story don't have to make sense from a real world perspective. They have to make sense from the perspective of the story world. When something happens that seems out of place in the story world you get jarred out of that world. So while I personally can't summon legions of zombies to obey my every whim nor can I suck the heat out of my enemies it makes sense that my online persona Recolada can. But if I could transform into a giant robot and shoot lasers out of my eyes that would break the immersion of WoW since it's a fantasy RPG in the Warcraft universe and not Transformers.
Now, in FFXI, my character is currently on the 6th mission in the main Windurst storyline. If memory serves this mission (which is the last one I did when I previously played the game, though I think I did the San'Doria version) involves researching events happening across the world and culminates in an epic fight with a giant dragon. This fight has a maximum level of 20, so if anyone came to help who was higher level they'd be forced down to level 20 for the fight. Does this break immersion?
I'm conflicted here. On the one hand, my mythical friend who has played for 5 years clearly should be a more powerful character. He's gained way more experience than I have. He's got way better gear. But when it comes down to killing this evil dragon we're on equal footing. Outside the dragon's lair, if we were fighting random bunnies, he'd destroy them in one attack while I may fight them for a minute. (White mage: bad at beating down.) But face to face with epic evil we're the same. This doesn't feel right, so it breaks immersion.
On the other hand, we have this evil dragon. He's causing all kinds of problems with the world and needs to die. My friend, and thousands of others like him, can kill him in one attack. How exactly is this dragon still alive and causing problems? This doesn't feel right either. Certainly in a Final Fantasy story environment the idea of a trivial epic fight just doesn't make sense. Even if we ignore that this dragon somehow survives all the high level players, having a huge build-up to a boss that dies in one hit shatters immersion.
Contrast this to a new player in World of Warcraft who is leveling through the Northrend content. The Big Bad keeps showing up in a bunch of your quests. He taunts you at every turn. He tricks you into helping Drakkuru betray his own people. Everything builds up to you wanting to get that guy. And you can't. It's simply not possible for the new player to actually assault Icecrown Citadel and take down the Lich King on equal footing. You can get a friend to come solo Marrowgar for you while you stand around and watch but it's just not feasible for a new player to find a raid of appropriate powered characters to take it on. The Lich King deserves better than to be a triviality to be updated 6 years from now like Ragnaros and Nefarian got this expansion.
Ragnaros is a good example too. He's _the_ Firelord. Assaulting his lair and taking him down in classic WoW took guts and effort. He was big and scary and hard. But give people a week digging through poop on another planet and suddenly he's a complete joke? Why, exactly, didn't my 40 man raid just go do that for a couple days and come back in and trivially stomp him?
But those are just expansion issues. WoW has two other huge immersion problems for me, one of which was actually brought in to solve the whole world not changing problem with why my FFXI dragon is still alive after being killed. That would be phasing, where the world 'changes' for you after meeting certain objectives. The problem arises when two people are trying to play together but are at different stages in the chain. I can be in the same part of the world, standing directly beside my friend, and be unable to interact with them in any way. Not because they're more powerful than I am so it doesn't make sense to work together but because the game prevents me from seeing him or doing anything with him. Immersion is increased for a single person in a vacuum but gets blown apart when two people in different phases try to interact. (Or when one person tries to pick an herb that is in the other phase...) The other is the dungeon finder which allows characters to instantly teleport into a dungeon with strangers, clear the dungeon out, and instantly go back to where they are. Convenient? Absolutely. Good for the game? I think so. But immersive? Not in the slightest. The physics of Warcraft simply don't work that way. Getting summoned to a warlock, ok, fine. Hearthing to your home point? Stretching it, but fine. Instant teleport to someplace at random to coincide with 4 other unknown people at the start of a level appropriate dungeon? I don't buy it.
But back to the level synch system. Does it break immersion? Yes, it is weird to have a character lose powers for seemingly no real reason. But I'd argue that it existing for boss fights like the dragon or Icecrown Citadel actually serves to fix a greater immersion break. And I strongly feel that even for random grinding it is a net positive addition to the game. Sometimes gameplay trumps immersion like in the case of the dungeon finder in WoW and I feel level synch does the same thing in FFXI. The ability to always play with your friends trumps the weirdness of a character powering down. (And in reality coming to terms with the fact you can't play with your friends also hurts immersion since it makes you more aware of the fact that you're playing a game with arbitrary rules about who can do what when.)
Imagine what it could do in WoW. Assume Icecrown Citadel is fixed as a level 80 zone no matter what. People who are level 85 could still run it, but they'd be as strong as they were at 80 instead of at 85. They could run it with their new friends so they could see the content as challenging fights. You could even make the bosses drop a relevant but not overpowering amount of valour points, too. The bridge dungeon between Cata heroics and Cata raids? Why not have it be ICC? This is quality content that is already tested. It's just sitting there begging to be used. Force anyone who zones into MC to become level 60. Then Ragnaros doesn't become a joke at all. He's still _the_ Firelord. Going in and killing him would remain an actual goal and achievement for new or old players alike. Maybe he wouldn't get visited very often since the loot would stay outdated but he doesn't exactly get visited very often under the current system either and him being a joke to kill doesn't make any sense at all.
So, does FFXI have immersion breaks? Yes, absolutely. They have sacrificed immersion in some places in order to make gains in other areas. WoW also has immersion breaks, also to make gains in other areas. Neither game is designed with immersion as the primary goal. They're both trying to be games that have consistent and immersive worlds but they both make concessions in order to be better games. But I don't think Square cares less about immersion than Blizzard does and certainly neither of them places an overwhelming emphasis on it to the exclusion of game play, which I for one am thankful for!
I did some searching and apparently the concept of immersion is a pretty fleshed out concept. Historically this has been in terms of books and revolves around the idea of "suspension of disbelief". Things in the story don't have to make sense from a real world perspective. They have to make sense from the perspective of the story world. When something happens that seems out of place in the story world you get jarred out of that world. So while I personally can't summon legions of zombies to obey my every whim nor can I suck the heat out of my enemies it makes sense that my online persona Recolada can. But if I could transform into a giant robot and shoot lasers out of my eyes that would break the immersion of WoW since it's a fantasy RPG in the Warcraft universe and not Transformers.
Now, in FFXI, my character is currently on the 6th mission in the main Windurst storyline. If memory serves this mission (which is the last one I did when I previously played the game, though I think I did the San'Doria version) involves researching events happening across the world and culminates in an epic fight with a giant dragon. This fight has a maximum level of 20, so if anyone came to help who was higher level they'd be forced down to level 20 for the fight. Does this break immersion?
I'm conflicted here. On the one hand, my mythical friend who has played for 5 years clearly should be a more powerful character. He's gained way more experience than I have. He's got way better gear. But when it comes down to killing this evil dragon we're on equal footing. Outside the dragon's lair, if we were fighting random bunnies, he'd destroy them in one attack while I may fight them for a minute. (White mage: bad at beating down.) But face to face with epic evil we're the same. This doesn't feel right, so it breaks immersion.
On the other hand, we have this evil dragon. He's causing all kinds of problems with the world and needs to die. My friend, and thousands of others like him, can kill him in one attack. How exactly is this dragon still alive and causing problems? This doesn't feel right either. Certainly in a Final Fantasy story environment the idea of a trivial epic fight just doesn't make sense. Even if we ignore that this dragon somehow survives all the high level players, having a huge build-up to a boss that dies in one hit shatters immersion.
Contrast this to a new player in World of Warcraft who is leveling through the Northrend content. The Big Bad keeps showing up in a bunch of your quests. He taunts you at every turn. He tricks you into helping Drakkuru betray his own people. Everything builds up to you wanting to get that guy. And you can't. It's simply not possible for the new player to actually assault Icecrown Citadel and take down the Lich King on equal footing. You can get a friend to come solo Marrowgar for you while you stand around and watch but it's just not feasible for a new player to find a raid of appropriate powered characters to take it on. The Lich King deserves better than to be a triviality to be updated 6 years from now like Ragnaros and Nefarian got this expansion.
Ragnaros is a good example too. He's _the_ Firelord. Assaulting his lair and taking him down in classic WoW took guts and effort. He was big and scary and hard. But give people a week digging through poop on another planet and suddenly he's a complete joke? Why, exactly, didn't my 40 man raid just go do that for a couple days and come back in and trivially stomp him?
But those are just expansion issues. WoW has two other huge immersion problems for me, one of which was actually brought in to solve the whole world not changing problem with why my FFXI dragon is still alive after being killed. That would be phasing, where the world 'changes' for you after meeting certain objectives. The problem arises when two people are trying to play together but are at different stages in the chain. I can be in the same part of the world, standing directly beside my friend, and be unable to interact with them in any way. Not because they're more powerful than I am so it doesn't make sense to work together but because the game prevents me from seeing him or doing anything with him. Immersion is increased for a single person in a vacuum but gets blown apart when two people in different phases try to interact. (Or when one person tries to pick an herb that is in the other phase...) The other is the dungeon finder which allows characters to instantly teleport into a dungeon with strangers, clear the dungeon out, and instantly go back to where they are. Convenient? Absolutely. Good for the game? I think so. But immersive? Not in the slightest. The physics of Warcraft simply don't work that way. Getting summoned to a warlock, ok, fine. Hearthing to your home point? Stretching it, but fine. Instant teleport to someplace at random to coincide with 4 other unknown people at the start of a level appropriate dungeon? I don't buy it.
But back to the level synch system. Does it break immersion? Yes, it is weird to have a character lose powers for seemingly no real reason. But I'd argue that it existing for boss fights like the dragon or Icecrown Citadel actually serves to fix a greater immersion break. And I strongly feel that even for random grinding it is a net positive addition to the game. Sometimes gameplay trumps immersion like in the case of the dungeon finder in WoW and I feel level synch does the same thing in FFXI. The ability to always play with your friends trumps the weirdness of a character powering down. (And in reality coming to terms with the fact you can't play with your friends also hurts immersion since it makes you more aware of the fact that you're playing a game with arbitrary rules about who can do what when.)
Imagine what it could do in WoW. Assume Icecrown Citadel is fixed as a level 80 zone no matter what. People who are level 85 could still run it, but they'd be as strong as they were at 80 instead of at 85. They could run it with their new friends so they could see the content as challenging fights. You could even make the bosses drop a relevant but not overpowering amount of valour points, too. The bridge dungeon between Cata heroics and Cata raids? Why not have it be ICC? This is quality content that is already tested. It's just sitting there begging to be used. Force anyone who zones into MC to become level 60. Then Ragnaros doesn't become a joke at all. He's still _the_ Firelord. Going in and killing him would remain an actual goal and achievement for new or old players alike. Maybe he wouldn't get visited very often since the loot would stay outdated but he doesn't exactly get visited very often under the current system either and him being a joke to kill doesn't make any sense at all.
So, does FFXI have immersion breaks? Yes, absolutely. They have sacrificed immersion in some places in order to make gains in other areas. WoW also has immersion breaks, also to make gains in other areas. Neither game is designed with immersion as the primary goal. They're both trying to be games that have consistent and immersive worlds but they both make concessions in order to be better games. But I don't think Square cares less about immersion than Blizzard does and certainly neither of them places an overwhelming emphasis on it to the exclusion of game play, which I for one am thankful for!
Monday, April 11, 2011
Final Fantasy XI: Level Synching
Tom introduced me to a new feature yesterday which is so awesome it's amazing. I'm honestly astonished that World of Warcraft hasn't added some variant of this feature. (I was first introduced to this style of feature 6 years ago in City of Villains.) The basic idea is the party leader can choose a person in their party to synch up with. Then every character in the party who is higher level than the targeted person gets leveled down to the same level as the target. They lose any abilities learned above that level. They have their skills capped as if they were actually that level.
The party then gets to gain levels as though the characters were actually the lower level. This experience gain gets applied to your 'real' level, but you gain it by fighting mobs appropriate to the target. FFXI has a 'merit point' system so people at max level can keep gaining experience to buy marginal stat increases. If someone is max level and gets synched up with someone lower they still gain merit points! So there's actually an incentive for max level characters to help out their buddies. Not only is an incentive; it's actually possible. In World of Warcraft if I had a friend start fresh now they'd have no actual way to play with my main character in any meaningful way for months. With the synch system we can have actual challenges fighting level appropriate mobs the whole way up.
When I used to play FFXI there were level down effects when you fought level capped bosses. However, when that happened, you couldn't gain experience and your gear fell off if you couldn't use it at your new level. The gear falling off part has, thankfully, changed too. Now if you could equip your gear with your real level and can't with your new level your gear actually gets deleveled too. The stat boosts on your gear get decreased proportionally in a way that isn't 100% clear. I saw a post from Square saying it would be worse than optimal appropriate level gear but that it's better than the alternative which is naked. It does mean you don't need to carry around a set of level 20 gear if you want to fight the level 20 bosses. If a specific piece is awesome you can still store it, but it frees up a lot of bank space.
There are a few restrictions, most notably that the target has to be at least level 10 and you all need to stay within range of the target to gain experience, but it seems really incredible.
The party then gets to gain levels as though the characters were actually the lower level. This experience gain gets applied to your 'real' level, but you gain it by fighting mobs appropriate to the target. FFXI has a 'merit point' system so people at max level can keep gaining experience to buy marginal stat increases. If someone is max level and gets synched up with someone lower they still gain merit points! So there's actually an incentive for max level characters to help out their buddies. Not only is an incentive; it's actually possible. In World of Warcraft if I had a friend start fresh now they'd have no actual way to play with my main character in any meaningful way for months. With the synch system we can have actual challenges fighting level appropriate mobs the whole way up.
When I used to play FFXI there were level down effects when you fought level capped bosses. However, when that happened, you couldn't gain experience and your gear fell off if you couldn't use it at your new level. The gear falling off part has, thankfully, changed too. Now if you could equip your gear with your real level and can't with your new level your gear actually gets deleveled too. The stat boosts on your gear get decreased proportionally in a way that isn't 100% clear. I saw a post from Square saying it would be worse than optimal appropriate level gear but that it's better than the alternative which is naked. It does mean you don't need to carry around a set of level 20 gear if you want to fight the level 20 bosses. If a specific piece is awesome you can still store it, but it frees up a lot of bank space.
There are a few restrictions, most notably that the target has to be at least level 10 and you all need to stay within range of the target to gain experience, but it seems really incredible.
Sunday, April 10, 2011
Final Fantasy XI: Hunts
Tom mentioned yesterday that he found a quest to kill a bunch of onion mobs until a named onion spawned and then he got some weird rewards for killing the named onion. This sounded suspiciously like camping NM (Notorious Monster) mobs for loot back in the day so I figured I should do some searching to see if I could find what it was he did.
It turns out hunts are exactly that. Square took the existing NM mobs with the myriad of ways the spawn and just tacked on a system of rewards to encourage people to camp them again long after the loot may be relevant. They still drop the same stuff they used to drop (well, with some exceptions, but those got changed for other reasons and not as part of the hunt system). But if you were going to go camp a mob for the loot anyway you might as well pick up the appropriate hunt to get some bonus rewards. And if you want the rewards you might as well go camp some easy to spawn NMs!
But what are the rewards for doing these hunts? Well, it looks like there are 2 rewards for doing so. The first is a type of currency used solely to start higher level hunts. The second is a random glyph you can insert into a socket on your gear for a buff of some kind. (Tom got one that decreased the cooldown on one of his abilities. I got a couple that increased my magic defense against certain types of monsters.) Nothing too exciting thus far, but if you have gear with sockets (etchings in this game) you might as well fill them with something.
Unfortunately it looks like nothing comes with an etching by default. You need to level a new profession (synergy) in order to add etchings to things. Synergy seemed interesting enough but certainly nothing I'm level appropriate for at this point. On the plus side the glyphs vendored for a substantial amount of money for a low level character (700g each) so I was pretty happy to have camped the two I did.
It turns out hunts are exactly that. Square took the existing NM mobs with the myriad of ways the spawn and just tacked on a system of rewards to encourage people to camp them again long after the loot may be relevant. They still drop the same stuff they used to drop (well, with some exceptions, but those got changed for other reasons and not as part of the hunt system). But if you were going to go camp a mob for the loot anyway you might as well pick up the appropriate hunt to get some bonus rewards. And if you want the rewards you might as well go camp some easy to spawn NMs!
But what are the rewards for doing these hunts? Well, it looks like there are 2 rewards for doing so. The first is a type of currency used solely to start higher level hunts. The second is a random glyph you can insert into a socket on your gear for a buff of some kind. (Tom got one that decreased the cooldown on one of his abilities. I got a couple that increased my magic defense against certain types of monsters.) Nothing too exciting thus far, but if you have gear with sockets (etchings in this game) you might as well fill them with something.
Unfortunately it looks like nothing comes with an etching by default. You need to level a new profession (synergy) in order to add etchings to things. Synergy seemed interesting enough but certainly nothing I'm level appropriate for at this point. On the plus side the glyphs vendored for a substantial amount of money for a low level character (700g each) so I was pretty happy to have camped the two I did.
Saturday, April 09, 2011
Final Fantasy II: What To Do?
Final Fantasy II is a game that eschews the normal gain experience to go up in levels system. Instead you have levels for everything you can possibly do and you get better at something by doing it. Want to get better with a sword? Attack with a sword. Want to get better with Ultima? Cast Ultima. Want to get more maximum health? Take a bunch of damage.
Unfortunately the system is wide open to abuse. Want to get better with swords, and with shields, and get more strength, and more vitality, and more maximum health? Try hitting yourself in the head with a sword over and over and over again. The poor imp you're engaged with won't know what's going on but you don't care!
I looked around a bit and couldn't find any challenges to do in this game. In fact, it just seems plain hard and no one really seems to like it very much. I've only beaten it once so just playing through normally could be the right plan... But how to define normally? Normally for me where I'll hit myself with a sword for 15 hours and then cakewalk through the game or normally in the sense that my characters will only take actions I normally would in a different game. No hitting yourself with a sword. No cast life on people who aren't dead. Etc. I worry this will make the game practically impossible though since I simply won't get to level up spells like life to the point where they're useful.
Unfortunately the system is wide open to abuse. Want to get better with swords, and with shields, and get more strength, and more vitality, and more maximum health? Try hitting yourself in the head with a sword over and over and over again. The poor imp you're engaged with won't know what's going on but you don't care!
I looked around a bit and couldn't find any challenges to do in this game. In fact, it just seems plain hard and no one really seems to like it very much. I've only beaten it once so just playing through normally could be the right plan... But how to define normally? Normally for me where I'll hit myself with a sword for 15 hours and then cakewalk through the game or normally in the sense that my characters will only take actions I normally would in a different game. No hitting yourself with a sword. No cast life on people who aren't dead. Etc. I worry this will make the game practically impossible though since I simply won't get to level up spells like life to the point where they're useful.
Friday, April 08, 2011
HOW I MINE FOR FISH?
![]() |
| The realities of MMO life. |
Now, there is a quest in the game to get the best fishing rod that merely requires trading 10000 fish to an NPC. This fish could be caught with no fishing skill in one of the starting towns. People who earned gil in other ways but wanted the fishing rod would pay a reasonable price for these fish. It doesn't take a genius to realize you can make a lot of money setting up computers to bot fish these fish up, sell them to actual players, and then sell the gil online. Square did nothing about this for a long time but eventually decided the economy was blown way out of whack and started aggressively attacking people who sold gil online and apparently did a pretty good job of it, but in the process they screwed with the players as well.
They changed fishing in a good way by making it more interactive. You now have to play a little mini-game to catch your fish. This would kill trivial bots for sure but I'm certain I could write a good enough bot in less than a day to play the new game. (Note: I wouldn't do that. I'm just saying it's not hard.) They also put in a hard cap on the number of things you can catch each day. As you get closer to that cap you have to wait longer and longer between tries until eventually you can't try at all. This cap is 200 catches for most people, but if your account is less than 30 days old or if your job level is less than 20 the cap is 10 catches. So I can't realistically fish for a month. *sigh*
Fishing isn't the only gathering profession hit like this. The other one that got hit hard since I played is gardening, which I used to actually do on 2 alts in addition to my main character just to grow more stuff.
What is gardening? Well, in FFXI each person gets their own house which they can put furniture and decorations in to provide a minor buff to themselves. One of the things you can put in your house in a flower pot. (Well, you can actually put up to 10 flower pots in your house.) Then you can plant seeds in these pots to grow stuff. You need to examine the plants every day to make sure they aren't dying and you can feed them crafting crystals to help them grow. Depending on the seed you'll get stuff anywhere from a week to a month later.
Now, there is a seed type you can buy from a vendor. And it grows into something that sells to the vendor for way more than the cost. I hope people can see the problem here, too. Gil sellers would open up trial accounts, garden like mad by vendoring everything, and introduce a ton of gil into the economy. Not just gil sellers, either. I found a blog about a guy who did this to finance buying a top level item or something. Apparently you used to be able to buy a trial cd for $2. So this guy went around and bought all of them he could find anywhere near where he lived. He went through about 100 of them, apparently. He'd run 16 accounts with 16 characters each every month. So he was examining 2560 pots a day which apparently took him 3 hours a day to do. But he'd also have to set up 256 characters with the pots, seeds, and crystals to start with and would spend a couple days straight not sleeping or going out to set them all up. (How paying $200 and 15% of your life to make 10M gil appear from a vendor can be considered ok but paying it to someone else for their gil is not is a little confusing to me, but I digress.)
This guy was doing it and so were an awful lot of other people - real players and gil sellers - so Square eventually stepped in to crack down on it. Me, I'd remove the seeds from a vendor or nerf the vendor value of the product. Instead Square made it so any account created within the last 90 days gets terrible results from gardening. Most recipes make tons of stuff from a bag of seeds, new players get 1 item maximum. I used to garden for corn so I could cook it into bait with my cooking skill. The recipe to make corn typically yielded in the 12-24 corn per seed range. A new player would get 1. Which pretty much destroys any hope a new player has of doing practically anything of value with gardening. (There are some recipes that only yielded 1 good thing anyway, so those should still be ok.)
Of course there are other ways to gather raw materials and as far as I can tell the other ones haven't been nerfed simply because you had to level up to do them. Fishing and gardening could be done just as well on a new level 1 as on a max level character. (Kinda why I wanted to start in on them again... Oh well!) I figure it's worth going over the other ways of gathering stuff too just to have it all in one spot.
Mining, excavating, logging, harvesting: These all entail wandering around the world looking for spawn points and then using a gathering item on the spawn point. Spawn points don't look like anything special and I don't think there's any way to detect them like there is in WoW, but you can target them by tabbing around. (Tabbing becomes force of habit in FFXI. I found a hidden wall yesterday when I was doing a mission with Tom entirely by accident because I was hitting tab instinctively.) When you find a mining node you target it, walk up to it, and use a pickaxe on it either by selecting it from your inventory or using a macro. (/item Pickaxe
Chocobo digging: Essentially this involves mounting up on a chocobo and feeding it gysahl greens to make it dig up items. There is a hidden skill associated with this gathering profession and you need to spend a lot of money on greens at a loss before you get to the point where you can actually make money. Since I both don't have a chocobo nor money to throw away this isn't a big concern for the time being. They also added a cap here to limit the number of times you can dig in a day similar to fishing which puts a real damper on leveling it up as well. (The site I found says it takes about 28 months to cap now if you get all your digs in every day which seems insane.) I imagine I'll do this for fun if I get some greens in some other way beyond buying them but for now it isn't a concern.
Clamming: This is a mini-game where you find clamming nodes and add clams to your bucket trying to get as close as possible to your bucket maximum without going over. Go over and you break your bucket and lose everything. You get to keep the stuff you clam up, so I think there's strategy in terms of knowing what you have and if it's worth risking it for something more and maybe busting your bucket. Apparently if you come very close to going over but stay under you can upgrade to a bigger bucket. Not really sure how it works since it's on an island covered with level 40+ mobs. Something to look into for the future I guess!
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)
